Maccabees Games

A look at the New York sports scene and the sporting world at large.

Monday, January 07, 2008

The Second Coming

NY Giants fans are beside themselves over yesterday’s performance of Eli Manning. Accolades such as ’he played great,’ ‘he finally turned the corner’ and the sort, were heard throughout homes with large screen HDTV and 26 inch sets alike.

But hold on just one second. Rising from the ashes of mediocrity, as one reporter qualified Eli’s performance, is not the second coming of Joe Montana, Tom Brady or Phil Simms.

Though Eli is still a mediocre quarterback, he did play well and fortunately for his team and his own psyche did not have any turnovers.

Watching the game I still saw throws off his back foot, wobbly thrown balls and passes closer to the turf than to a receiver’s hands.

However, I also saw a playoff performance reminiscent of one from times gone by. Manning’s 20-27 with 185 yards with no interceptions took me back to the days of another Giants quarterback who in 5 playoff games, completed 72 of 115 passes (62.6 percent) for 1034 yards, 7 touchdowns, no interceptions, and a 112.0 passer rating while going 4-1.

Further, with his next team this Giant ‘great’ went 27-39 for 524 yards in 2 games with 4 touchdowns and no interceptions and a 69.2% completion percentage.

So is Eli Manning the second coming of great Giant quarterbacks of the past? Well sort of or maybe. But don’t look back at the names of Tittle, Tarkenton, Simms et al. Look instead to that ‘other’ Giant quarterback who gave the Giants their last Super Bowl. Look to that other quiet, nonplus personality (except for his mustachioed face), who should remind you in some respect to Manning’s performance at Tampa Bay, ironically at the very same field where the Giants blew their last chance at a Super Bowl in 2001. I refer to none other than to the one and only, Jeff Hostetler.

Welcome to the second coming.


Blogger Uri said...

let's see how the rest of the post season plays out and see what everyone says when all is said and done. dallas should be tough!

6:43 PM  
Anonymous judah h said...


7:40 PM  
Anonymous superfeldman said...

Second coming? I never thought of Eli Manning in the same category as Jesus and the Lubavitcher Rebbi. Will Giants' fans split into two camps: those who accept Eli Manning as the Messiah and those who do not? All second comings always cause trouble for Jews.

8:10 PM  
Anonymous judah h said...

He was always considered the Messiah by some. What we don't know is if the Mannings were truly sired by L. Ron Hubbard. Moreover, is Eli really the father of Suri Cruise?

10:06 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home